8 comments

  • ValentineC 33 minutes ago
    We used to have Yakult Ladies in Singapore too — I remember my parents buying from them to please their kids (me) decades ago.

    Surprisingly enough, I just looked the scheme up for this comment, and it's still active:

    - https://yakult.com.sg/yakult-lady-agent/

    - https://sg.news.yahoo.com/memory-makers-singapores-first-yak...

    The Yahoo article could help explain some of the economics behind it.

  • Aaargh20318 38 minutes ago
    Every time I read an article about people trying to solve the 'loneliness epidemic' I can't help but wonder if we're not trying to solve the wrong problem.

    Maybe the solution should not be sought in trying to increase social connections but in eliminating our need for social contact. This dependence on other humans has always felt like a flaw to me.

    Note that I'm not saying that human contact is bad, just that our pathological dependency on it is.

    • kelipso 20 minutes ago
      This is the kind of detached from humanity viewpoint that I come to hacker news for. Keep it up.
    • fsckboy 7 minutes ago
      >Every time I read an article about people trying to solve the 'loneliness epidemic...

      you're reading the title wrong, they aren't "trying to solve the loneliness epidemic," they are trying to sell yogurt at a profit. In so doing, their sales force is ameliorating some of the loneliness their clients feel as a side effect. You could say that they are monetizing loneliness if that's the reason people are buying their products, for the visits and not for the yogurt.

      • Aaargh20318 4 minutes ago
        Exactly. This need to be social is being used against us. Not just to sell yoghurt, it’s weaponized by the social media networks to manipulate entire countries.
    • jatari 4 minutes ago
      Yes, how do we optimize social interaction out of our lives, maybe we can all live in VR with simulated girlfriends and never have to interact with another human again.
    • onlyrealcuzzo 36 minutes ago
      Then, like, what's the point of even being a human instead of a robot?
      • jatari 1 minute ago
        Nothing wrong with being a robot.
      • Aaargh20318 11 minutes ago
        To learn, to create, to grow? None of these things necessarily involve other humans.
      • MattGaiser 31 minutes ago
        You would be free to decide, instead of having it being biologically required that you socialize.
    • sa-code 30 minutes ago
      What’s there to live for otherwise? Can you flesh this idea out more?
      • Aaargh20318 6 minutes ago
        There are plenty of things to live for, but that’s not even the point. There is a difference between choosing to be social and having to be social because you will get depressed if you aren’t.

        I think this need for social interaction is harmful. We did see this in action during the COVID pandemic. So many people who weren’t able to abide by a short lockdown. Lives were lost due to our pathological need for social interaction.

        Imagine how many communicable deceases we could eliminate by simply having a 3 month lockdown every other year.

        • charlie0 3 minutes ago
          You don't go far enough, every flu season should be lockdown and social distancing protocol should be followed on pain of death.
      • MattGaiser 7 minutes ago
        It would be up to you. These people who are lonely otherwise have lives.
    • neilv 21 minutes ago
      Techbros are thinking: "Don't eliminate their need! They need a subscription AI app!"
    • kalterdev 35 minutes ago
      > The thinking child is not antisocial (he is, in fact, the only type of child fit for social relationships). When he develops his first values and conscious convictions, particularly as he approaches adolescence, he feels an intense desire to share them with a friend who would understand him; if frustrated, he feels an acute sense of loneliness. (Loneliness is specifically the experience of this type of child—or adult; it is the experience of those who have something to offer. The emotion that drives conformists to "belong," is not loneliness, but fear—the fear of intellectual independence and responsibility. The thinking child seeks equals; the conformist seeks protectors.)

      https://aynrandlexicon.com/lexicon/loneliness.html

  • _delirium 1 hour ago
    The article didn't answer my main question, which is how the economics work. How does it add up to have high-touch home delivery of $5 yogurt packages?
    • trollbridge 1 hour ago
      It's very effective if you have just a few of these, but are able to get lots of press from doing so that causes many other consumers to go and buy yourself through normal grocery outlets.
      • MagicMoonlight 58 minutes ago
        They don’t have just a few, they have 81,000 people doing it.
    • VLM 58 minutes ago
      400 yen for a ten pack is more like $2.50 than $5

      Typical markup in the USA is 100% from wholesaler to retail. Running brick and mortar is very expensive. So if Walgreens were selling this, the wholesale price would be $1.25. I think it reasonable to expect the Yakult Ladies are pulling in the same $1.25 per package that walgreens gets.

      The key, I think, is "Most of them are self-employed". Its a gig economy idea. You have to eat. If you're walking home from the store anyway (or kids school or on the way home from work or whatever), you may as well deliver packages for $1.25 each on the way home. You're walking home anyway, you may as well make free money on the walk.

  • jokoon 15 minutes ago
    English is not my main language but this title confuses me
  • haunter 1 hour ago
    This is an ad
    • cubefox 1 hour ago
      I thought the BBC was state funded and didn't have to rely on undisclosed sponsorships.
      • rounce 47 minutes ago
        The BBC is not state funded, it's a public broadcaster primarily funded by the general public, via the (admittedly outdated) TV licence fee system. Although the media output for the UK is non-commercial, it does have commercial operations and interactions though and they are mostly centred around the content produced for overseas consumption. As this post is on the .com domain where the international content exists (and which runs ads), I presume it is part of the paid content side of things.
        • umanwizard 6 minutes ago
          > The BBC is not state funded, it's a public broadcaster primarily funded by the general public, via the (admittedly outdated) TV licence fee system.

          How is that different from being state-funded? Everything state-funded is paid for by the general public, through taxes. That's part of what being a state is: an organization that forces people to pay taxes and directs them to various programs.

          Are you claiming that the TV license fee isn't a tax? It's money that the state makes you pay so that it can fund something.

        • nephihaha 7 minutes ago
          The BBC is a state broadcaster which claims to be autonomous, but that doesn't apply when it comes to foreign policy or the royal family.
        • wizzwizz4 40 minutes ago
          Correct. The .co.uk version has this disclaimer:

          > This website is produced by BBC Global News Ltd, a commercial company that is part of BBC Studios, owned by the BBC (and just the BBC). No money from the licence fee was used to create this website. The money we make from it is re-invested to help fund the BBC’s international journalism.

      • cjs_ac 40 minutes ago
        From the footer:

        > This website is produced by BBC Global News Ltd, a commercial company that is part of BBC Studios, owned by the BBC (and just the BBC). No money from the licence fee was used to create this website. The money we make from it is re-invested to help fund the BBC’s international journalism.

        • RenThraysk 38 minutes ago
          In the UK, the bbc.com link redirects to bbc.co.uk and the notification footer auto closes before even have a chance to read it.

          And if it is an ad, doesn't the FTC require it to be labelled as such?

          • rounce 28 minutes ago
            Why would the US FTC have any jurisdiction?
            • RenThraysk 4 minutes ago
              Because of US audience.

              There was a case where UK based influencer got into FTC trouble for the CSGO Lotto gambling site. He was promoting it without disclosing he had a stake in the site.

      • Nursie 43 minutes ago
        BBC.com is a commercial service aimed at people outside of the UK
      • MagicMoonlight 58 minutes ago
        They probably aren’t even getting paid for it, they’re just falling for shill posts for free.
        • cubefox 2 minutes ago
          I'm not sure which would be worse.
    • nephihaha 1 hour ago
      From the BBC no less. We were just discussing how uncommercial they are.
  • ekianjo 25 minutes ago
    Is this a PR piece, with product placement clearly front and center?
  • alephnerd 1 hour ago
    This seems to be a submarine article - all the images and quotes seem to be directly sourced from Yakult Honsha's strategic comms department.

    Edit: yep, appears Yakult has just kicked off an ad campaign putting Yakult Ladies front and center [0]

    [0] - https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=u8HNY7Ta4dA

  • tokyobreakfast 41 minutes ago
    Japanese have lactose intolerance, almost universally.

    They don't eat yogurt or dairy in general.

    • gramie 19 minutes ago
      The annual consumption of ice cream in Japan was 6.7 litres per person in 2021 (compared to 10 litres/person in Canada and 20 litres/person in the U.S.). For all dairy, Japanese people each ate 94 kg in 2022.

      They eat less dairy, but hardly none. I have heard people say that a scoop of ice cream or a glass of milk each day is not a problem, but more can be. Intolerance also seems to increase with age, so younger people can consume more dairy.

      A 1975 study in Japan puts intolerance (unable to drink 200ml of milk comfortably) at 19% of the population. I would suspect that massive exposure over the past 50 years has lowered that percentage significantly.

    • umanwizard 5 minutes ago
      The first line is true, the second line is false.

      Lactose intolerance is not absolute.

    • tokai 14 minutes ago
      How come Yakult is a nearly 100 years old Japanese company?

      Most yogurt cultures reduces lactose content of the milk base during fermentation. Some cultures like the one Yakult uses supports increased lactose digestion in humans. At the same time lactose intolerance is not binary but a spectrum.

    • wingerlang 39 minutes ago
      So does Thailand but we also have Yakult ladies here, they just sell the drinks though.