The Sicilian Citrus Family Tree

(notesfromtheroad.com)

115 points | by wmchen 4 days ago

11 comments

  • chicken-stew 16 hours ago
    During lockdown, I started citrus plants from seed (they’re polyembryonic and have a copy from the parent plant). I really wanted Clementines, you never see those in nursery catalogs, the sweet ones with the thin skin that falls off. So I dived into the literature to find out more about its history and … no consensus whatsoever. There’s one pile of publications claiming it’s a hybrid from this and that parent, and a diff pile of papers stating it’s most definitely not a hybrid but a mutation. So whenever I come across a poster like this I feel the urge to ask the author: why are you in the hybrid origin camp?
    • erik-gauger 5 hours ago
      Great question, and deep in the weeds for a travel writer to have an opinion on. But I did similar projects on chilis, yuccas and cacti, and learned that botanists and horticulturists ask different questions. To me, botanists think about where the plant came from while horticulturists and gardeners ask what separates one variety from another.

      The clementine is a hybrid...a 2014 genome study found it to be a cross of the Mediterranean mandarin and a sweet orange. As far as I can tell, the papers about mutation are about clementine varieties, which are bud mutations of the original tree. So the clementine is a hybrid, and its varieties are mutations of it. I don't grow citrus myself, but a few days ago I bought a clementine and my favorite thing about it - and what separates it from other citrus, is how it sprays so much zest in the air and that scent is from heaven.

    • leobg 12 hours ago
      I always thought citrus doesn’t grow true from seed, that you cannot predict the result, and that it’ll most likely be some regression to the og citron, like thick skinned, bitter, little juice and lots of seeds. You’re saying this is just one theory? What did you find when growing yours?
      • chrisgarand 7 minutes ago
        Citrus mostly grows true to type from seed. Depending on the variety, they can be polyembryonic, monoembryonic, of a mix of the two.

        There's a lot of bad information out there about seeds, and growing true to type, here's a list for what to expect, keep an eye on the headers because they're mixed into the list: https://redwoodbarn.com/PDF/Whichcitrusfromseed.pdf

        A note to consider, just because it's polyembryonic, doesn't mean you'll want to grow it. Some of the citrus can take as long as 15 years to fruit. Others, like key limes, can go from seed, to picked fruit in a year and a half.

      • chicken-stew 11 hours ago
        With Citrus it’s wild: in a lot of hybrids and species (not all) you get seeds that will sprout 2 or more seedlings from the same seed. One seedling will be the result of pollination (with the reshuffled genes as you describe) while the others will be a clone of the motherplant. You let them grow next to each other and remove the odd ones. Mine haven’t flowered yet, my climate is too cold and this prolongs the period to first flowers.
  • madads 13 hours ago
    Incredible work. This is fantastic. I've always wondered about the origins of lemons, and how there seems to be many varieties in my local supermarket but they're all just labelled lemons, despite being very different at different times of the year.

    I was on the hunt for actual bergamot, as I love Earl Grey tea, and they've mostly sythesized the aroma/taste as oil spray's, and I wanted to make my own Earl Grey with real bergamot. Maybe this is the beginning of my adventure...

    • erik-gauger 5 hours ago
      I don't know where you are based, but bergamot should be easy to find in higher end grocery stores in North America right now. Go down the rabbit hole...! One way to taste bergamot is through bergamot marmelade...and bergamot peel as a pairing for cheese. One of the most unique flavors on Earth.
    • Gibbon1 13 hours ago
      If you want another rabbit hole to go down, look at Cherries. But citrus is definitely weirder.
  • skyberrys 20 hours ago
    This is interesting. I wonder where Australian citrus fits in with this? Do you know about finger limes aka caviar limes fit in this image?
    • erik-gauger 19 hours ago
      This project was about how citrus affected Sicily for a 1000 years. I have been pondering the possibility of continuing citrus travelogues elsewhere; there are so many fascinating stories: Algeria, Australia, Philippines, New Orleans, China, Japan, etc, etc. But your note makes me happy because once I finished this series, I started trying every citrus not related to Sicilian history I could get my hands on. Finger limes are one of my favorites. Bergamot is so weird, and it is the best marmelade. Regardless of whether I do more citrus travelogues, I will get to a global Citrus poster within a year.
      • skyberrys 4 hours ago
        I'll try to find bergamot to try. I never realized it's a citrus based tea. The citrus stories are fascinating, the plants are so flexible it seems. I encourage you to keep going with it!
      • metalman 12 hours ago
        "kinu", found in Lahore and of course many other versions in the Punjab, can only be had fresh, will not ship far at all, glorious as hand food or juice, cheap like borsh when in season.

        got side tracked in your blog, got as far as the 'european roller' and had to bail, as an invenerate road tripper who has been 'house camping' for perhaps too long, only clicked because I am reading 'on the road' presently, shuddering as the wildest moments overlay perfectly with some of the things I did, which is to say, your NOT helping thanks

    • chrisgarand 18 hours ago
      You might like this video, I saw it awhile ago, it goes over all of the citrus, and their history: https://youtu.be/XkMKJCvJKBk?si=SaRVH8qcQMx2i5x_&t=811

      I linked to the Australian portion, there's a second part that talks about migration.

      The TL:DR is that one thought is Kumquat was their origin, but it's only a theory.

      • skyberrys 4 hours ago
        Thank you that was cool to read! I must have a local farmer into Australia citrus because I've tried most of those Australian ones. The little round limes were so intense tasting!
      • ThePowerOfFuet 12 hours ago
        Tracking-free YouTube link: https://youtu.be/XkMKJCvJKBk?t=811
  • translucenthund 16 hours ago
    There's one type missing, the so called Vanilla orange (arancia vaniglia)

    It exists only here from what I know, it's a non sour orange that I believe it has been created in Sicily, or at least I haven't seen or read about it anywhere else. Very interesting

    • erik-gauger 5 hours ago
      Oh wow, the Vaniglia of Ribera...a spontaneous mutation, which would put it on the chart with the other Sicilian sweet oranges. I read about this one when I started the project, but there was no way to cover every citrus in Sicily; I chose the ones that carried the story in the series. But your post here is making me consider adding a few, and this is one of them, along with the Mapo tangelo. Now I want to see if I can find a vanilla orange here in the US. Is it your favorite, and is it really distinctive?
    • leobg 12 hours ago
      You are from Ribera?
    • fuzzfactor 7 hours ago
      >a non sour orange that I believe it has been created in Sicily,

      Sounds like they could make you an orange juice you couldn't refuse . . .

  • gus_massa 3 days ago
    Related "A ternary plot of citrus genealogy" https://www.jlauf.com/writing/citrus/ (HN discussion https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47238272 (170 points | March 2026 | 37 comments))
    • erik-gauger 20 hours ago
      That is a really cool chart...I wish it would include micrantha, which it references but doesn't include in the triangle...but really cool way to visualize it.
  • somat 22 hours ago
    Only tangential, but it reminds me of how the cure for scurvy was found, then lost. https://idlewords.com/2010/03/scott_and_scurvy.htm Basicly, the danger of using something you don't understand. It mostly works, Until it doesn't and you can't fix it.
    • thaumasiotes 17 hours ago
      Note that the cure for scurvy was never lost. It had been known for several thousand years already and it remained known continuously through the period you indicate.

      But the official policies of the British Royal Navy did go through a cycle of not having any effective approach to scurvy, then having an effective approach, and then not having an effective approach again. That isn't because the knowledge was lost.

  • pg_bot 1 day ago
    Aren't all of the citrus fruits native to South East Asia?
    • erik-gauger 20 hours ago
      Yes, the series is about how citrus from Southeast Asia impacted every aspect of Sicilian culture, cuisine and politics for 1,000 years. Let me know what you think of Chapter 5, which is about the wild fruits.
    • chasil 1 day ago
      Many of the hybrids originated elsewhere.

      "Grapefruits originated in Barbados in the 18th century."

      https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grapefruit

      • erik-gauger 20 hours ago
        Yup, and that it what the series is about. Let me know what you think if you get a chance to read it.
  • motionlessveloc 19 hours ago
    Citrus ancestry is stupidly complex, and the generally commercially available varieties sadly few.

    You may have heard of yuzu, which was a foodie fad a couple of years ago (and deservedly so, it smells & tastes great). In Japan, it's only one of numerous citruses, including dekopon (navel mandarins, occasional sold in Australia as "sumo"), tachibana, kabosu, sudachi, etc.

    Hop a few islands down to Okinawa, and the fruits change yet again! Here you have shikwasa (hirami lemon), tachibana, tanibuta, etc.

    An incomplete list on Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japanese_citrus

    • jan_m_savage 11 hours ago
      there is also a citrus called Guo Dong Cheng in China (where guo is from shui guo [fruit], and cheng is from cheng zi [orange]) which tastes very different from both kinu, chou ju (ugly orange), and has no seeds. It's mildly tart yet still sweet enough to make you eat three or four without feeling the need to stop. :)
    • thaumasiotes 17 hours ago
      In 2023 calamansi juice was stocked in every supermarket in Shanghai.

      In 2024, it suddenly vanished.

      I've been wondering what happened.

  • exmadscientist 22 hours ago
    I love posters like this one!

    Unfortunately when I try to shop for them nowadays they're all AI slop. Is it too much to ask to get a nice Encyclopedia of Pastries poster? Apparently it is.

    • erik-gauger 19 hours ago
      Thank you! One reason hand-drawn posters are rare is how long they take. The citrus plate at the bottom of this page is 25 fruits and took me roughly 100 hours; my chili poster took about 500 because it was 176 fruits. Nobody does that work to make money on a poster. There has to be an underlying editorial reason to draw the thing in the first place. For me, I am like you...I always wanted to see these things as posters and they never existed. Speaking of pastries, that Great British Bakeoff must have thousands of those pastry and cake illustrations that they use to illustrate the show.
      • thaumasiotes 17 hours ago
        > Nobody does that work to make money on a poster.

        You reminded me of something. I was looking at a book of artwork with my brother and he commented that some of the art was bad because there was too much drawn in the background.

        I think this is a case of "misplaced advice" - the belief that background artwork lowers the overall quality of a piece is false, but it persists because it is helpful to artists.

        If you're trying to sell your artwork, people will pay a lot more for foregrounds than they will for backgrounds, but backgrounds aren't any easier than foregrounds - generally they're harder - so any time you spend drawing stuff in the background effectively lowers your hourly earnings. (Unless the level of background detail in your art is so low that it's making it all unsaleable.)

        But if you ask people about what artwork they like, background detail is always helpful.

    • VladVladikoff 21 hours ago
      You can get some decently high resolution images on Wikipedia commons which are scans of old hand drawn illustrations in books. Then (I know, I know) use an AI tool to enlarge the images to a high enough resolution that they print nicely. There are task specific tools just for enlarging that do a pretty decent job if you aren’t trying to go more than 2x. But the scans are usually enough that you only need to slightly enlarge them to get to a resolution that prints 300dpi at a reasonable size.
  • chasil 1 day ago
    I wonder if any Sumo or Tangelo is grown there. These are in season and available in the U.S. in the early spring.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dekopon

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tangelo

    • erik-gauger 20 hours ago
      Great question. In Sicily, there is a specific tangelo called the Mapo, although it is a very small crop. Sumos are grown only in California, I believe. Here in Portland, we are just starting to get tangelos and sumos, but they all seem early and a little bland. In other month, it's citrus heaven. Since I just finished this series, I have been trying to taste any citrus I can. I love finger limes and bergamots.
  • margalabargala 22 hours ago
    This doesn't actually answer the question. It lists the parentage of some other varieties, and then lists a bunch of blood oranges without saying where they came from.

    Claude can make some very interesing, informative, accurate sites to present information. This isn't an example.

    • erik-gauger 20 hours ago
      Hi, this is an epilogue from an 8 chapter series that explains all of those things. Note that there are chapter links to each of those 8 chapters. For the chapter on blood oranges, I spoke with agronomists, ecologists and historians, and sketched a blood orange grove. The fruits shown on this epilogue are the fruits that I discussed in the series.
      • margalabargala 20 hours ago
        Good for you for doing all that prior to prompting your post.

        Would be nice if any of what you said was clear from the thing actually posted. Maybe a more detailed prompt next time?

        Posting the final post in a series and then expecting people on a random site to have read all prior series posts is not a good look.

        • erik-gauger 19 hours ago
          Fair point that the page didn't stand on its own. I didn't submit it; it was written as an epilogue for people who had already read the series, so it assumed all of that context. It's the last page of a 30,000 word essay and was never linked as a standalone page. I've since added an intro explaining what it is, links to all eight chapters at the top, and where each fruit originated. I was at the theatre this evening, when I started seeing traffic and these comments, so I rushed home to make the clarifications.