4 comments

  • gr-mk 16 minutes ago
    This might impact me and a small handful of other people who have messing around with microbes in their apartment as a hobby. We'll see what happens.
  • __MatrixMan__ 1 hour ago
    The device used to make oligonucleotides is pretty much an inkjet printer, from there it's cleverly applied enzymes to assemble the full strand. If you've got the skills and determination to get the synthetic DNA into a functioning cell, I don't think limiting access to synthetic DNA in the first place is going to stop you.
    • car 32 minutes ago
      The device used to make oligonucleotides is pretty much an inkjet printer, from there it's cleverly applied enzymes to assemble the full strand.

      Usually the synthesis of oligonuclotides is done with phosphoramidite chemistry [0]. So tell us more about those enzymes to make DNA molecules from scratch.

      [0] https://www.twistbioscience.com/blog/science/simple-guide-ph...

    • xscott 28 minutes ago
      I'm only asking because I dislike fearmongering, and you seem knowledgeable: what about a virus? Prion disease?

      Red team it: What's the worst you could do?

  • King-Aaron 1 hour ago
    > U.S. government–funded scientists who make and manipulate DNA sequences will face tougher regulations

    Seems like this has little to do with deterring terrorism then, considering the assumption that a terrorist may not be a US government funded scientist.

    • Glyptodon 19 minutes ago
      My guess is that the assumption is that US gov funded labs are enough of many suppliers revenue that it'll be effective, but I'm 100% speculating and it may be total garbage speculation given that I have no idea how much hobbyist level DNA projects are a thing or how much they're a thing for non-medicinal business purposes.
    • CamperBob2 41 minutes ago
      Trouble is, that assumption hasn't always worked out in the past: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bruce_Edwards_Ivins

      But yes, this is stupid. No one who is inclined to build a biological WMD is going to be more than mildly inconvenienced by supply restrictions. DNA isn't plutonium.

  • janalsncm 55 minutes ago
    > It’s great, because it does something instead of nothing

    I am detecting a bit of frustration here.

    • InsideOutSanta 18 minutes ago
      Yeah, I'm assuming that was intended to be sarcasm.

      (Also, my comment is great, because I wrote something instead of nothing.)