I thought "cold" lights were weird and unnatural. One day I was walking to my bedroom and realized I left the sun lamp (which I classified as weird and unnatural) turned on, based on the glare coming from around the corner. And then I walked into the room and discovered that no, that was just the natural sunlight, and the lamp was turned off. Whoa. So that ugly light I hated was much closer to the real thing than I'd realized.
I finally, after meaning to set something up for years, bought https://getbrighter.com/ . It works, does the job; very expensive, but likely paid back itself within weeks in terms of sleep and productivity improvements. It's bright enough that I rarely need it on full brightness (And does both warm and cool light).
but probably everyone has noticed they’re more lethargic on cloudy days.
Not everyone; I can focus and think a lot more easily without bright light, and of course everyone who closes their eyes when in deep thought is doing that because they want the darkness. I suspect this could be related to how some people like to work early hours, while others prefer later hours.
> everyone who closes their eyes when in deep thought is doing that because they want the darkness
That's not self-evident to me. I assume it has more to do with borrowing the visual cortex for image or image-like thought processes, which is easier without the distraction of stimulus. Thus, it's not darkness per se, but blankness that is desired. And since bright light is a whole body sensation, not just a stimulus for the eye, closing one's eyes doesn't actually bring darkness at all.
I would love a system that could detect when I was pre-emptable and when I was not by looking at the kinds of activity I was doing on the computer.
Unfortunately that sounds exactly like a tool that management would use to PIP people who weren't staying busy enough. Including the guy who everyone asks for help.
Best upgrade I've made to my ranch house has been adding a couple solar tubes to my dark living room. Each one has a light collector on the roof and a reflective tube down to the ceiling. They were $1500 each but now I've got plenty of natural sunlight. It's not as bright as being outside, but it's bright enough that the first few days around noon it seemed like too much and I wore a hat. Now that I'm not used to living in a cave, it's great.
I've been eyeballing those forever. Our friends' new neighbors installed some before they moved in, and I may be misremembering but I believe the previous owners added one.
They do seem to work better on low-pitch roofs, since they lose a lot of light the longer the pipe is.
Some lose more than others. I got the Solatube brand which claims to have an especially reflective coating; they give numbers compared to other brands. It seems believable since our roof pitch isn't that low, and one of the lights in particular has a fairly long tube. Still really bright.
LED lighting has gotten even better since 2019. My WFH desk is in a dark corner. I am currently in the process of speccing out a high-CRI, soffit-mounted LED strip to wash the wall behind my monitor: https://store.waveformlighting.com/products/dynawhite-dim-to...
This product has built-in “warm dim” support from 4000K to 3000K on a common PWM dimmer. No separate DMX module or 0-10V line required. The result will be an entire wall of broad-spectrum light brightening my work environment, balancing out the light from my monitor, and improving my mood by emulating morning or evening light.
Not if you pay for a good one. That strip is rated for PWM cycles of 30KHz, which is considered flicker-free. A quality driver that can handle the load of 4 foot of that product should be under $100.
AYO looks lifted from a plot line from Northern Exposure that I've not thought about in a lot of years. I just ordered a pair in hopes that they end up being more convenient than trying to stay in one place near a bright light. Certainly cheaper / easier than the various unfinished and unstarted DIY winter lighting projects I've considered.
If I were independently wealthy, I'd have a ceiling of those Coelux sun simulator panels.
I find where you grew up have impact on your light needs... closer you're to equator you need more light, and people lived there are accustomed to sharper, cooler midday sun colour temperature too. Whereas the higher latitude you go people are used to lesser light and warmer shades.
Preferences aside, LED really need a common standard when it comes to flickering and colour rendition it's getting to the point it's being compared with smoking in terms of health effects.
If I had to choose though, the old halogen lights were a blast. 500 - 750W halogen linear bulbs were great. Such warm festive feel! Go grab one for your xmas holidays in your home, dimmable too as it's just a resistor glowing... black body radiation baby!
I've heard one of the problems with more polar people visiting the equator is not having any good instincts about how long twilight is. Us northerners have a notion of the dying light being the last call an we can get in one or two more things outside, while equatorial people know that it was instead the warning that the bar is closing and you need to wrap it up.
There was a post about "brighter" the startup a few months back which was built for the same purpose which was quite insightful, unfortunately with such a generic brand name I cannot find that post anymore.
There's a really cool video I saw on youtube a while back where a guy made an artificial skylight.
So the human brain seems to be able to tell the difference between the coherent light from the sun and a sun lamp. Whether that's purely psychological or has a physiological component is somewhat mooted by the fact that if you're unhappy, your body is also unhappy.
He took a square array of LEDs and positioned them at the focal length of an old DirectTV dish, then silvered the dish. The focal point of most dishes collects a coherent signal, so reversing the direction produces a mostly coherent beam from the point light source.
Now the downside of this approach is he needed a void behind his fake window to accommodate the depth of his projector and the heat production. IIRC he just mounted it on the door to the room so it stuck into the hallway, but that seems like it I personally wouldn't buy that arrangement. And if you have roof access, a sun pipe might be a better option and cause less circadian rhythm disruption.
And then he topped it all off by sandwiching water between two plates of acrylic and adding a tiny amount of soap to scatter blue light a bit. That part I would probably skip. Certainly there's some sort of window cling that could mimic the effect without presenting a water damage hazard.
If I were to accomplish this, I'd look into getting LED strips in crown molding (or something similar) so you get nice spread-out indirect light instead of single corn-cob blasting in the corner.
The regular ones were up to 100W, but it was possible to buy the high-wattage ones (up to 300W I think?), intended for older appartments with very high ceilings and similar.
It's crazy to think how much electricity was spent just for lighting not so long ago.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zr-eZ_pLTNI shows a 30000W incandescent lightbulb the dude bought. I think it was intended for a lighthouse. Much higher wattages were available as arc lights.
I bought a bunch of 3000K LED strip lights over COVID. Definitely one of my highest benefit/cost ratio purchases ever. I much prefer the strip lights since it distributes light more evenly.
extremely simple idea and very helpful -- I bought a big daylight LED light panel for less than $100 and it did seem to work for me! Obviously hard to distinguish from placebo since you can't be blinded (pun intended)
Another thing I'd highly recommend for people struggling with shorter days is the Philips SmartSleep Wake-up light [1]. The price is a bit insane for a light, but it's so much gentler than cheaper no-name options I've tried. It has a very dim starting brightness, the "steps" as it ramps up are imperceptible, and the color gradually shifts from very warm to less warm.
I don't think this will help at all in the way of SAD treatment (not bright enough), but it does make mornings more pleasant.
I have this and love it. Underrated is its wind-down feature at night, where you press a button to turn it on at full brightness, then over a period of time you set (I have mine at 45 minutes) it gets redder and dimmer, like a sunset. I've found it a great way to slow down at the end of the day.
I do wish it had day-of-week alarms, so it'd automatically wake me up at the same time each day. As it is, if I forget to set it today, it won't go off tomorrow. That said, almost every alarm clock I've ever owned has been like that so it's not some egregious failure. Out of habit, when I turn off the alarm each morning, I press the button again to turn it back on so it triggers a day later.
A bunch of huge honking off-road led bars. Neat solution. That's stuck with me for a long time.
I've had 3x mid sized (~50w) corn bulbs for a while myself. Rarely am I blasting it though. The aluminum reflectors people build makes me think perhaps just getting something more directional would be better but the extra diffusion probably is worth losing some of tht light for.
The article here is missing recommendations on bulbs. I can soft recommend Aries series
, have been fine for me: I have a mark 2 and a mark 3. There's a new mark 4. Many units have builtin adjustable dimming and now color control (warmth). Example, this 120w e39 bulb: https://www.ledlightexpert.com/120-watt-led-corn-bulb-5700k-...
Another way to look at it is that US house design sucks, both in the type, size and placement of windows, and because the presence of a closet in an office is a very bad idea because it makes one of the walls unviable for setting a desk.
Very few houses have rooms explicitly designed to be an office, but the presence of a closet, especially in a small room, sabotages its use any other way.
It also depends where in the US one lives. Closer to the equator and SAD will be less of a concern. Up north when there are only 8-9 hours of daylight (and it's often overcast) then the article becomes much more of a solution than better windows.
I grew up in Rome, which is almost at the same latitude as Boston, and SAD was never such a big problem, as described in the blog <<having “crippling” seasonal depression>>.
Look at the picture in the blog and you'll see what's wrong: he set the desk in front of a window, which he covered to avoid getting the sun in his eyes, and the window on the left - the smaller of the two - is partially covered. This way, it's no surprise he's suffering from low amounts of light !
Why did he do this ? After living a decade in Canada and the US, and having seen many houses both on the East and West coast, North and South, I can venture a guess: behind the desk there are two walls that can't be used to set a desk because they're encumbered by a door, by a closet and possibly an HVAC return vent. Especially the closet is pretty useless in an office: you can't cover it because a closet needs space for air circulation so that makes an entire wall too narrow for a desk and often too inconvenient because too close to the door.
Why didn't I have a problem in Italy ? Because my office was designed much better:
* building code in Italy requires a minimum ceiling height of 2.70m (9ft) but in practice nobody builds that low and it's more common to have houses with a ceiling between 3m and 3.5m. That allows windows to be taller and let more light in.
* windows are also often wider than in the US/Canada (even more light in)
* there's no closet
* the entrance door and the window are on the same side of the room, on the left and right corner next to one of the short sides of the room. That leaves nearly 3 walls of uninterrupted space that one can turn into office space.
> Is it bad for the planet? Not at all: it's half as bad as [something so wildly bad for the planet that foregoing it is by far the most effective way any individual who currently eats beef can help combat climate change].
Not everyone; I can focus and think a lot more easily without bright light, and of course everyone who closes their eyes when in deep thought is doing that because they want the darkness. I suspect this could be related to how some people like to work early hours, while others prefer later hours.
That's not self-evident to me. I assume it has more to do with borrowing the visual cortex for image or image-like thought processes, which is easier without the distraction of stimulus. Thus, it's not darkness per se, but blankness that is desired. And since bright light is a whole body sensation, not just a stimulus for the eye, closing one's eyes doesn't actually bring darkness at all.
And some like me like to switch. Either early morning or late at night. Basically when most other people are asleep and not bothering the flow.
But few things make me as awake and clear minded, as a bright sunny day coming after rainy days. Then I cannot be inside a cave.
Unfortunately that sounds exactly like a tool that management would use to PIP people who weren't staying busy enough. Including the guy who everyone asks for help.
They do seem to work better on low-pitch roofs, since they lose a lot of light the longer the pipe is.
This product has built-in “warm dim” support from 4000K to 3000K on a common PWM dimmer. No separate DMX module or 0-10V line required. The result will be an entire wall of broad-spectrum light brightening my work environment, balancing out the light from my monitor, and improving my mood by emulating morning or evening light.
The AYO glasses made the biggest difference for me. Took about 2-3 weeks of consistent use for me to notice the effect.
Those coupled with the light box have made the winter months much more bearable.
If I were independently wealthy, I'd have a ceiling of those Coelux sun simulator panels.
Preferences aside, LED really need a common standard when it comes to flickering and colour rendition it's getting to the point it's being compared with smoking in terms of health effects.
If I had to choose though, the old halogen lights were a blast. 500 - 750W halogen linear bulbs were great. Such warm festive feel! Go grab one for your xmas holidays in your home, dimmable too as it's just a resistor glowing... black body radiation baby!
this one?
So the human brain seems to be able to tell the difference between the coherent light from the sun and a sun lamp. Whether that's purely psychological or has a physiological component is somewhat mooted by the fact that if you're unhappy, your body is also unhappy.
He took a square array of LEDs and positioned them at the focal length of an old DirectTV dish, then silvered the dish. The focal point of most dishes collects a coherent signal, so reversing the direction produces a mostly coherent beam from the point light source.
Now the downside of this approach is he needed a void behind his fake window to accommodate the depth of his projector and the heat production. IIRC he just mounted it on the door to the room so it stuck into the hallway, but that seems like it I personally wouldn't buy that arrangement. And if you have roof access, a sun pipe might be a better option and cause less circadian rhythm disruption.
And then he topped it all off by sandwiching water between two plates of acrylic and adding a tiny amount of soap to scatter blue light a bit. That part I would probably skip. Certainly there's some sort of window cling that could mimic the effect without presenting a water damage hazard.
edit: apparently this is called "cove lighting"
Wow, that's ridiculous.
Converted to light emitted by traditional light bulbs, it's more like 40 bulbs of 60W.
https://ledhut.co.uk/blogs/news/led-equivalent-wattages-agai...
It's crazy to think how much electricity was spent just for lighting not so long ago.
I don't think this will help at all in the way of SAD treatment (not bright enough), but it does make mornings more pleasant.
[1] https://www.amazon.com/Philips-Simulation-Headspace-Subscrip...
I do wish it had day-of-week alarms, so it'd automatically wake me up at the same time each day. As it is, if I forget to set it today, it won't go off tomorrow. That said, almost every alarm clock I've ever owned has been like that so it's not some egregious failure. Out of habit, when I turn off the alarm each morning, I press the button again to turn it back on so it triggers a day later.
A bunch of huge honking off-road led bars. Neat solution. That's stuck with me for a long time.
I've had 3x mid sized (~50w) corn bulbs for a while myself. Rarely am I blasting it though. The aluminum reflectors people build makes me think perhaps just getting something more directional would be better but the extra diffusion probably is worth losing some of tht light for.
The article here is missing recommendations on bulbs. I can soft recommend Aries series , have been fine for me: I have a mark 2 and a mark 3. There's a new mark 4. Many units have builtin adjustable dimming and now color control (warmth). Example, this 120w e39 bulb: https://www.ledlightexpert.com/120-watt-led-corn-bulb-5700k-...
Look at the picture in the blog and you'll see what's wrong: he set the desk in front of a window, which he covered to avoid getting the sun in his eyes, and the window on the left - the smaller of the two - is partially covered. This way, it's no surprise he's suffering from low amounts of light !
Why did he do this ? After living a decade in Canada and the US, and having seen many houses both on the East and West coast, North and South, I can venture a guess: behind the desk there are two walls that can't be used to set a desk because they're encumbered by a door, by a closet and possibly an HVAC return vent. Especially the closet is pretty useless in an office: you can't cover it because a closet needs space for air circulation so that makes an entire wall too narrow for a desk and often too inconvenient because too close to the door.
Why didn't I have a problem in Italy ? Because my office was designed much better:
* building code in Italy requires a minimum ceiling height of 2.70m (9ft) but in practice nobody builds that low and it's more common to have houses with a ceiling between 3m and 3.5m. That allows windows to be taller and let more light in.
* windows are also often wider than in the US/Canada (even more light in)
* there's no closet
* the entrance door and the window are on the same side of the room, on the left and right corner next to one of the short sides of the room. That leaves nearly 3 walls of uninterrupted space that one can turn into office space.
speak for yourself: https://i.pinimg.com/736x/50/5e/d7/505ed7d668a4d3a9ce04a8757...
Wow! Let's all get one! Power is cheap, folks! /s