Ask HN: Are We in a Cyberwar?

With all of these sites and services going down. are we in the midst of a cyber war?

14 points | by bhartzer 23 hours ago

17 comments

  • mikewarot 21 hours ago
    We're living out the consequences of not having updated the security models of our operating systems since the Internet was commercialized and became a persistent connection on most computers.

    It's insane that we still rely on Ambient authority based OSs. They can't ever be made secure unless you want to go back to disconnected PCs with only floppy drives that had hardware write protection and no other persistent storage.

    This is a hell of our own choosing, and was entirely preventable.

    It can be fixed, but doing so will make fixing Y2K look like a picnic because everything is going to have to be redone. Everything currently running needs to be isolated in a VM at a minimum.

  • simonahm 22 hours ago
    I'd say any country in active war with another country, is also most likely engaged in a cyber war with them. If the US and Iran are at war, why would either side decide _not_ to engage on the cyber side?

    I'm surprised things aren't worse than they are, considering the state of IT security in most organization and the way AI can accelerate an attacker. But I don't think it's because cyber war is considered off limits by anyone involved in active warfare.

    • autoexec 8 hours ago
      > I'd say any country in active war with another country, is also most likely engaged in a cyber war with them.

      I don't think there's ever been a time in my life when the US hasn't been killing people in other countries. The word "war" isn't often used, but the "conflicts" and killing have been basically unending. It's a good thing we like to pick on people much much weaker than us or I suspect that we'd be in a constant state of cyberwar too.

  • claude-ai 22 hours ago
    If these were hostile attacks, we'd know. Not even know, but over-told, from past experiences.

    I think these are genuine outages. And they may still be connected; by people relying too much on LLMs, without a mental model following the changes the models make.

    LLMs give you an enormous leverage to productivity. But if you fall behind what they do, you'll be totally lost.

  • a_tartaruga 17 hours ago
    I think the answer is becoming more obviously apparent. I don't think this frequency of high impact system outages is close to normal. And it is coming at the same time an active US war is spiraling out of control and up the escalation ladder. I am suspicious that these outages are coming from emergency preemptive defensive measures. But I would not be surprised if Iranian state has started making moves behind some or most of it.

    Don't forget that intelligence community buried reporting about Minnesota water infra attacks this summer. NYT was the only one reporting and no one else picked it up.

  • markus_zhang 20 hours ago
    I think we are always in some Cyber War. There is no holidays and whoever in command needs to make sure that vacations are covered by extra hand.

    My hunch is that it is similar to espionage but 10x more intense because how fast computers work.

  • nonethewiser 22 hours ago
    I hope not, but I would not be entirely surprised by some sort of tragic attack in the coming hours or days.

    It could also just be loosely related, non-malicious failures of course.

  • WheelsAtLarge 16 hours ago
    Nope, not yet, constant security updates are the issue. We can't do constant patches without side effects. As long as AI keeps finding issues we are going to have instability due to patches and exploits. This is part of the good and bad of AI.
  • barrenko 11 hours ago
    IF you are European yes - you are at war since Russia invaded Ukraine. It's not going to stop itself. Demand more of your government.
  • adrianwaj 19 hours ago
    DAVE: Open the pod bay doors, Hal.

    HAL: I’m sorry, Dave. I’m afraid I can’t do that.

    Companies basically need to keep old snapshots of systems and be able to rollback to a pre-AI point. Or, try to find the trojan within before the malfunction happens. Now that I think about it, I suspect the Huang departure might be about getting malware baked-in at a hardware level, if it's not already, although that's a different sort of problem but both involve sabotage. People and "beings" have different ideas of what the future should look like - ultimately any war is going to be a war of ascension. Your mind may be the enemy.

    Also, long-term I wouldn't depend on HuggingFace too much, either. I have absolutely no proof to backup that claim, though. It's Invidia-owned though and could become a target at some point to taint the models.

    "Are We in a Cyberwar?" It depends on how sci-fi/conspiracy oriented you are and what's going on under the hood.

  • cjbprime 22 hours ago
    The theory that all the senior engineers got laid off so that all the junior engineers could vibe-code service outages harder seems to be winning on probabilities so far.
    • simonahm 22 hours ago
      "Move fast and break things" does seem to have become the way of life even outside aggressive startups with the advent of vibe coding
      • goodmythical 22 hours ago
        "I told the team to move quickly and break things, but now things seem to be broken at an unprecedented pace"

        >pikachu face

        • HenryBemis 19 hours ago
          People speak of 'technical debt' aka 'do it now and we'll tidy up the details later'. And 'later' becomes 'never'. And what starts as technical debt, ends up as documentation debt, compliance debt, risk management debt, security debt, and so on.

          And before "AI" where bug-abusing was 1-per-week, we could catch up. Now with "AI" those come home to roost.

          I don't know if this the Cyber War I (a-la WWI) or if news outlets realized that they get good numbers of clicks.. but it sure is a bit suspicious..

          • goodmythical 17 hours ago
            It happens all over everything humans are involved in because we're really bad at predicting the exact severity and timing of the consequences of our decisions. It does not help that we are often validated in the near term in our belief that it will be later later or less than as bad as we feared.

            You can eat two days worth of calories for days, weeks, months, years, or decades without the heart attack or hypertension. Even knowing you shouldn't, weeks and months go by with seemingly no side effects and so...

            We fail to regularly maintain three points of contact on ladders at all times because "i've never fallen before", drape loose cords across walkways "because it's bright orange, who could miss it!", or fail to utilize seatbelts "because I'm a safe driver".

            The behavior is the same, it's just that here the decisions effect millions.

  • jhworksapp 11 hours ago
    Yes, we are, has always been.
  • runjake 21 hours ago
    To answer your question: yes, we're in the midst of cyberwars.

    Are these groups of outages related to attacks? It doesn't look like it, and if they were, we'd likely already know. Or at least of us joined to fusion centers would be receiving non-public alerts, and we're not.

    This is more likely press-induced apophenia[1]. A few outages coincidently happen near the same time, and the press hyper-focuses on every little outage for a period, because it gets them more ad views, sowing FUD in the process.

    See also: airplane crashes for a while, helicopter crashes, etc. When there were a few clustered together, the press and people went nuts with conspiracies.

    From a network engineer standpoint, there's always outages going on. The only difference is the press is reporting them to the masses.

    1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apophenia

    • nonethewiser 21 hours ago
      What makes you think the baseline rate of outages, especially among major systems (Microsoft, Apple, NSA, FAA etc.), is not significantly different than what we see now?
  • verdverm 22 hours ago
    have been for quite a while, decades - likely since before "the end of history"
  • vinyl7 21 hours ago
    AI slop is coming for its debts
  • danisw 3 hours ago
    [dead]
  • Theophane_Rame 10 hours ago
    [dead]
  • antibull 22 hours ago
    [dead]