This is an ok development in my opinion because cooling buildings with heat pumps or AC overlaps the demand curve with the solar production curve better than heating does.
Heating tends to be during shorter days and less solar production, making it trickier to cover the power needs with new energy alone.
Of course this doesn’t mean heating is going down, just that cooling is going up (unless populations are moving to warmer climes).
well, climate is getting warmer in general, so in a sense populations are actually moving to warmer climates. heating is probably going up anyway, but less than it would be if there was no global warming
Notably, heating a building adds heat to the local environment (heat your house and your neighbourhood gets warmer). Also, cooling a building adds heat to the environment (cool your house and your neighbourhood gets warmer).
When a building is 20C/68F on the inside and 30C/86F on the outside, Carnot says we ought to be able to cool that with a coefficient of performance of around 30x. Ie. 100 watts of electricity giving 3000 watts of cooling.
However real airconditioners get a coefficient of more like 3.
This strikes me as a massive engineering opportunity - the person to close that gap and be able to extract $$$ from the savings will become very rich.
They have a coating that can be applied to HVAC units which results in about a 40% improvement in energy efficiency. In the US it's distribution seems to be handled by Nu-Calgon and for whatever reason they branded it "CoolWorx" in addition to a data center focused version called "DataWorx."
The branding was bit of a shock because it takes something that's a potentially a global leap forward at a reasonable price and makes it look like something you'd buy off of an infomercial.
In terms of making your own home more energy efficient, the path is always cost optimized. You figure out where your energy bleeds are and fix them first because it's significantly better ROI than trying to add solar to cover everything. Then when you reduce your consumption enough, you don't need as much solar. Efficiency of your fridge, HVAC units, seals and temp loss from windows & doors. If you're in an area with rates that vary by time of day, home batteries that can charge when it's cheap and then use that when it's more expensive.
40% efficiency improvement in one of the most expensive utilities should be an automatic purchase for the price.
> They have a coating that can be applied to HVAC units which results in about a 40% improvement in energy efficiency.
Sorry to disappoint, but their coating will not do that.
As far as I can see, they've mixed some graphene into a corrosion protection coating. Then their marketing team abandoned reality and claimed 40% improvements in something.
Corrosion protection is important for extending service life of an HVAC unit, but the coating isn't going to increase efficiency by 40%, or at all. It's a film on top of the coils which technically reduces thermal performance, but the film is so small I guarantee this is negligible.
Maybe they're trying to claim that the graphene in the mix improves emissivity? You would achieve the same result by coating the coils with anything black, but that's a negligible factor.
Sorry to burst your bubble, but this company doesn't have anything that will change world energy consumption. It's a corrosion inhibitor with a little bit of graphene and a lot of marketing.
Ya, I was thinking it’s maybe in comparison to a coating that doesn’t have graphene or something. If it was a real 40% efficiency gain, manufacturers would already be applying it.
+1 I tried to skim through what they were measuring. My best guess was maybe the coating prevents grime/grease buildup so most of that was the difference between clean coils and dirty coils.
Correct me if I'm wrong but as I understand it this doesn't mean 40% more efficient AC, it's only the heatsink being 40% more efficient at dissipating heat?
You can make a system suck 40% less energy by improving one component enough to cross some threshold that makes whatever the energy suck is happen less (e.g. the difference between zero and some insulation on a fridge). That's easy.
Improving the heat transfer of a heat sink with a surface coating is hard (for reasonable definitions of "heat sink" and "surface coating") because you run right into physics.
Really? I guess making a heatsink dissipate 40% more heat is great for lots of applications (and hard), but it shouldn't translate to great gains in AC efficiency, right?
This is great, but more solar PV installs would help too -- they should pay for themselves in a reasonable amount of time for those with high electrical costs.
There’s a reason infomercials use that sort of language. It’s like when HN users are disappointed that the average of all human English language produces substandard (for them) AI-isms in the output.
Maybe they did focus group tests that showed that name got them the attention they needed in that market.
Painting surfaces for heat transfer is a 200yo trick. It's not worth 40%. It's more like +10%/-20% if you're being optimistic and using super modern engineered materials.
They must be making some weird marketing truck where they've set up some special situation where 10% improvement results in 4x that reduction in energy usage some other way For example in a heating context it's really easy to imagine how a 10% improvement to a heat pump could result in it kicking on the resistive heating much less in some climates for an overall 40% reduction in energy for the same set point.
If real world performance were anywhere near claimed without unacceptable tradeoffs (falls off if you look at it funny and then the dust gives you an incurable disease) and if you it would already be everywhere. Even if it cost as much as upsizing the hardware you'd see it space constrained applications.
15yr ago everyone was making the same silver bullet claims about ERV/HRV and it turned out those only really move the needle for very specific climates and building uses but the sellers are laughing all the way to the bank because the various codes and green this and that incentives that they got written into draw no such distinction.
The great news is that its usually only hot when the suns out, and AC units can be run from solar panels essentially for free. So we can sit in our air conditioned rooms without having to feel guilty for killing the planet.
It's a familiar problem to everyone in the energy industry. Solar alone isn't enough, you also need energy storage to time-shift the generation and the load.
On an individual scale, if you're into home automation you can do some tricks like pre-cooling the house below your target temperature while you're gone for the day. At one house where we had significant excess solar I briefly entertained the idea of having a cooling vent into the attic to try to make that space cold on days with excess generation available during the day.
> I briefly entertained the idea of having a cooling vent into the attic to try to make that space cold on days with excess generation available during the day.
My attic has spray foam insulation and the HVAC system (also in the attic) already does this to a mild extent. I can go up there in the middle of an August day and not feel it at all.
Allowing the ceiling above your living space to reach 140F+ starts to get into radiative heating issues. You don't need to cool the attic to 72F. Anything would make a huge difference. Radiative heating scales quartically with temperature.
My idea was to use excess electricity generation to cool the attic somewhat below the temperature of the living space. That space would then sink some heat after the sun went down, reducing the cooling demands in the evening.
An analogous idea would be to have a large water tank in the basement with a chiller attached. You run the chiller when you have excess electricity to get the water colder than the house, then let it passively soak up heat later.
It was all shower thoughts, but the idea of storing excess energy generation during peak as coldness (wording which makes pedants cringe) for evening cooling is not new. You can pre-cool your entire house, but having to wear a sweater for a couple hours every day during the summer is not fun after a while.
It drops, but not that much. They are rated at 25c, at 80c they produce around 80% of the rated output.
10kWp needs around 60m2 of roof space, and that's gonna be more than enough power to cool a single floor house four or five times that size. Multi floor buildings are more efficient, as there are less exterior walls/ceilings.
Solar's cheap enough that you can put on way more panels than you have demand for; speaking from experience. Due to the cheapness of solar, there are some things that are worth it that most people wouldn't expect - like if you mount panels at a suboptimal angle, you lose some peak production, but gain some in the off hours, which is a worthwhile tradeoff.
> without having to feel guilty for killing the planet.
Except what happens is not actual cooling, but spending energy to move the heat outside. In total we heat the planet, when we try to cool a small part down.
This is a silly take. If you use solar-derived electrical energy to move hear gained by solar heating from inside outside, you are not increasing the amount of heat gained from the sun. It’s literally solar energy all around.
You are converting light to heat. The whole issue of climate change is that more light is converted into other frequencies and heat, which then doesn't leave the planet as much anymore.
Solar panels have a drastically lower albedo than the surfaces they sit on. You know, because we want to actually capture that sunlight and turn it into electricity instead of reflecting it back out of the atmosphere.
>> So we can sit in our air conditioned rooms without having to feel guilty for killing the planet.
Well, you are using that power for your own comfort when it could be used to reduce carbon emissions. Instead of cooling your house, you could allow that power to be used by industry, say an aluminum smelter, and thereby reduce the amount of carbon being burnt to power that smelter. Or, instead of running your AC, that power could be sent to the factory that builds solar panels... making new panels cheaper for everyone.
And that's before counting gigawatt data centers burning 99.9999% of chip power as waste heat just to switch transistors—and then burning more energy to cool the rooms down. We need to stop heating the air.
Hasn't this always been the case? I remember hearing the fun factoid that the biggest mall in America (The King of Prussia) had no heating system at all (in Pennsylvania, not a warm place in the winter), just a cooling system.
Households used to be designed for temperature management, especially the very old ones - rooms that were used only part of the year, rooms that were designed for a purpose, and exceptionally large thermal mass basically everywhere.
The square-cube law makes especially large buildings like that weird examples to base a guess on.
But also the article seems to be going back and forth between whether it's talking about total energy use, or electricity use in particular. But either way, the shift is primarily because of an increase in availability of air conditioning in hot places, rather than a change in the balance in places which use both.
I've always wondered why systems like ammonia absorption chillers are not used more. They are low energy for fridges in trailers as they only need to heat the solution to just under 70C a few times a day or less. But getting that kind of heat from solar isn't difficult either.
"Measured by the fuel and electricity consumed, heating is still well ahead."
Then what "...as an energy need" supposed to mean? They even go on to use a better term in the article, “useful energy”: the energy that does the job people want.
I think the reasoning behind this is that a lot of places that have a growing need for cooling have never had a big need for heating. Anything close to the equator basically. Places like India, much of Africa, etc. Places with lots of people, rapid economical growth, and rapidly growing energy consumption.
Not disagreeing on useful energy (as opposed to final and primary energy), which are a bit technical terms and which the IEA likes to (ab)use to muddy the waters a bit. But it's a bit of a technical topic. But I think their assessment that cooling needs are growing rapidly while heating needs aren't is probably not wrong.
Since they are building data centers they should also build municipal water heating like in north Europe. We burn these gigawatthours, let’s at least heat people’s homes for free.
and towards this aim it will be useful for town planners to evaluate the lessons learned in truly hot climates like the middle east where economics of scale lead to a centralized municipal utility approach and it is charged like water or electricity hookups.
Having grown up in the US south, I confess it has been mind bending to find out how much of the world managed to get by without AC. It is super jarring to hear about the temperatures that made up heat waves in the UK.
Which, I get it. Nevada is hotter. Extremely so. But I also thought all of the middle east was hotter, as well. Not so much?
It does give me empathy to all of the people that laugh about how bad the US south is with snow. With the added amusement that Seattle is exactly the same on that front.
> It is super jarring to hear about the temperatures that made up heat waves in the UK.
It's not that complex as someone who lives in the UK, Buildings are built for the average climate you had over the preceding decades at the time they were built with the understanding that the outliers will happen, it's just a naturally lagging thing - We haven't caught up with the new reality that sustained periods of high heat (by our standards) are much more likely, the South East caught it particularly bad this year, London baked.
My house was built in the early 1980's, it's becoming less and less suited to our climate now and that'll get worse.
Long term the plan is to re-insulate the loft, insulate the walls, install shutters on the flat windows (and look at them for the bay windows, our windows are a pain as they aren't flat and they usually open outwards), heat pumps/AC and PV (complicated by roof been east/west but if you panel both you get not far off the same as the same area facing south and more nicely you get power in mornings/evenings which is when we use the most (for much of the year anyway)).
The house my boy inherits will be more suited for the climate he'll be living in when he inherits it (hopefully not for another 30-40 years but the universe may have other plans).
Humans evolved in a subtropical environment. The first permanent settlements were established in subtropical environments. Electric AC has been a thing for the most recent one thousandth of the history of our species. Me, I’m happy to live somewhere where it’s very rarely over 30°C but in general humans are biologically well adapted to heat.
Still, where I live a problem is that most residential buildings are designed to be warm in the winter first and foremost, without concern for potential summer overheating. But the latter has now become a real problem, and there’s often not much to do about existing buildings without extensive renovations but to install per-unit AC. At least there’s the fact that it can often be done with a heat pump so it’s also useful in the winter.
Teleheating is very common around here, and cities have started building telecooling networks to complement heating, simply circulating cold water to be used as a heat sink. But building comprehensive pipe networks is of course slow and expensive.
Heat isn't so bad if humidity is low but when it is hot AND humid it is very miserable. I normally run my AC just to lower humidity. Also at night I sleep MUCH better when the room temp is less than 70F
And as long as there isn't too much water in the air. People think of Miami, Florida as frequently above 100˚F because it feels that way, but it's actually never gone past that. It's just very humid.
Having grown up in the US South, I can tell you how -- most houses since the 1960s were designed around A/C, and are incredibly ill-suited if the A/C doesn't work.
I know this because I grew up in a house in Florida built in the 1950s, with no A/C. Southern vernacular architecture includes high ceilings (so the heat rises above the people), lots of windows (to let the air go through and heat escape), and with the house raised off the ground (so cooling air flows underneath). While my house didn't have it, another typical design element is a wraparound porch, to provide extra shade and let the windows stay open even when it rains.
If you build for A/C in the South then you want a building with good insulation and little airflow, to save on power. If the A/C doesn't run then these places get very warm, humid, and stuffy. Nearly every house is built this way.
Further, if you are used to the chill that A/C provides then your body doesn't adjust to the heat.
The US Southwest has its own vernacular architecture. The days are hot and the night cool, so use thick adobe walls which take 12 hours for the heat of day to seep through. Close the windows in the morning to keep the cool in, open them at night to cool off, while the heat from the walls keeps the inside more moderate.
>Having grown up in the US south, I confess it has been mind bending to find out how much of the world managed to get by without AC.
One unique characteristic of the eastern US is that people here live in a climate with hot and humid summers but imported the clothing norms of a subcontinent (Europe) with warm and dry summers. If you look at traditional — pre-colonial — dress in Africa or India, you'll find it's much less warm. Even in China, which resembles the eastern US from a climate perspective, loose and lightweight clothing (silk!) was much more common prior to the global adoption of western norms.
Heating tends to be during shorter days and less solar production, making it trickier to cover the power needs with new energy alone.
Of course this doesn’t mean heating is going down, just that cooling is going up (unless populations are moving to warmer climes).
> unless populations are moving to warmer climes
Rather: warmer climes are moving to populations
However real airconditioners get a coefficient of more like 3.
This strikes me as a massive engineering opportunity - the person to close that gap and be able to extract $$$ from the savings will become very rich.
That everywhere is warmer now so we need more cooling? (Implies global warming)
That developing countries need more cooling than heat? (Buried lead)
That datacenters make up the majority of new demand? (Misleading headline)
I see many comments here assuming it means continuous energy needs. From the article, we see the headline implies my second question:
> That growth comes mostly from hot countries that are getting richer.
https://graphenemg.com/graphene-products/thermal-xr/
They have a coating that can be applied to HVAC units which results in about a 40% improvement in energy efficiency. In the US it's distribution seems to be handled by Nu-Calgon and for whatever reason they branded it "CoolWorx" in addition to a data center focused version called "DataWorx."
The branding was bit of a shock because it takes something that's a potentially a global leap forward at a reasonable price and makes it look like something you'd buy off of an infomercial.
In terms of making your own home more energy efficient, the path is always cost optimized. You figure out where your energy bleeds are and fix them first because it's significantly better ROI than trying to add solar to cover everything. Then when you reduce your consumption enough, you don't need as much solar. Efficiency of your fridge, HVAC units, seals and temp loss from windows & doors. If you're in an area with rates that vary by time of day, home batteries that can charge when it's cheap and then use that when it's more expensive.
40% efficiency improvement in one of the most expensive utilities should be an automatic purchase for the price.
Sorry to disappoint, but their coating will not do that.
As far as I can see, they've mixed some graphene into a corrosion protection coating. Then their marketing team abandoned reality and claimed 40% improvements in something.
Corrosion protection is important for extending service life of an HVAC unit, but the coating isn't going to increase efficiency by 40%, or at all. It's a film on top of the coils which technically reduces thermal performance, but the film is so small I guarantee this is negligible.
Maybe they're trying to claim that the graphene in the mix improves emissivity? You would achieve the same result by coating the coils with anything black, but that's a negligible factor.
Sorry to burst your bubble, but this company doesn't have anything that will change world energy consumption. It's a corrosion inhibitor with a little bit of graphene and a lot of marketing.
> 10-50% energy reduction measured across commercial HVAC, chillers and data centres.
If the claim is 40% more efficient AC, that’s the whole system.
If it were only for, say, the heat sink component, thats only one component.
You see how one component being more efficient contributes only a fraction to the total system?
Improving the heat transfer of a heat sink with a surface coating is hard (for reasonable definitions of "heat sink" and "surface coating") because you run right into physics.
Maybe they did focus group tests that showed that name got them the attention they needed in that market.
They must be making some weird marketing truck where they've set up some special situation where 10% improvement results in 4x that reduction in energy usage some other way For example in a heating context it's really easy to imagine how a 10% improvement to a heat pump could result in it kicking on the resistive heating much less in some climates for an overall 40% reduction in energy for the same set point.
If real world performance were anywhere near claimed without unacceptable tradeoffs (falls off if you look at it funny and then the dust gives you an incurable disease) and if you it would already be everywhere. Even if it cost as much as upsizing the hardware you'd see it space constrained applications.
15yr ago everyone was making the same silver bullet claims about ERV/HRV and it turned out those only really move the needle for very specific climates and building uses but the sellers are laughing all the way to the bank because the various codes and green this and that incentives that they got written into draw no such distinction.
So yeah, color me skeptical.
It's called the Duck Curve because the graph kind of looks like a duck if you squint https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duck_curve
It's a familiar problem to everyone in the energy industry. Solar alone isn't enough, you also need energy storage to time-shift the generation and the load.
On an individual scale, if you're into home automation you can do some tricks like pre-cooling the house below your target temperature while you're gone for the day. At one house where we had significant excess solar I briefly entertained the idea of having a cooling vent into the attic to try to make that space cold on days with excess generation available during the day.
My attic has spray foam insulation and the HVAC system (also in the attic) already does this to a mild extent. I can go up there in the middle of an August day and not feel it at all.
Allowing the ceiling above your living space to reach 140F+ starts to get into radiative heating issues. You don't need to cool the attic to 72F. Anything would make a huge difference. Radiative heating scales quartically with temperature.
https://www.energy.gov/cmei/buildings/articles/unvented-cond...
My idea was to use excess electricity generation to cool the attic somewhat below the temperature of the living space. That space would then sink some heat after the sun went down, reducing the cooling demands in the evening.
An analogous idea would be to have a large water tank in the basement with a chiller attached. You run the chiller when you have excess electricity to get the water colder than the house, then let it passively soak up heat later.
It was all shower thoughts, but the idea of storing excess energy generation during peak as coldness (wording which makes pedants cringe) for evening cooling is not new. You can pre-cool your entire house, but having to wear a sweater for a couple hours every day during the summer is not fun after a while.
10kWp needs around 60m2 of roof space, and that's gonna be more than enough power to cool a single floor house four or five times that size. Multi floor buildings are more efficient, as there are less exterior walls/ceilings.
Except what happens is not actual cooling, but spending energy to move the heat outside. In total we heat the planet, when we try to cool a small part down.
Well, you are using that power for your own comfort when it could be used to reduce carbon emissions. Instead of cooling your house, you could allow that power to be used by industry, say an aluminum smelter, and thereby reduce the amount of carbon being burnt to power that smelter. Or, instead of running your AC, that power could be sent to the factory that builds solar panels... making new panels cheaper for everyone.
Found a link for the Mall of America: https://brokensecrets.com/2010/03/02/the-mall-of-america-doe...
edit: Should have read the article. It's taking into account households, which obviously have far less human thermal energy available than malls.
But also the article seems to be going back and forth between whether it's talking about total energy use, or electricity use in particular. But either way, the shift is primarily because of an increase in availability of air conditioning in hot places, rather than a change in the balance in places which use both.
"Measured by the fuel and electricity consumed, heating is still well ahead."
Then what "...as an energy need" supposed to mean? They even go on to use a better term in the article, “useful energy”: the energy that does the job people want.
Not disagreeing on useful energy (as opposed to final and primary energy), which are a bit technical terms and which the IEA likes to (ab)use to muddy the waters a bit. But it's a bit of a technical topic. But I think their assessment that cooling needs are growing rapidly while heating needs aren't is probably not wrong.
https://www.tabreed.ae/what-we-do
Which, I get it. Nevada is hotter. Extremely so. But I also thought all of the middle east was hotter, as well. Not so much?
It does give me empathy to all of the people that laugh about how bad the US south is with snow. With the added amusement that Seattle is exactly the same on that front.
It's not that complex as someone who lives in the UK, Buildings are built for the average climate you had over the preceding decades at the time they were built with the understanding that the outliers will happen, it's just a naturally lagging thing - We haven't caught up with the new reality that sustained periods of high heat (by our standards) are much more likely, the South East caught it particularly bad this year, London baked.
Not hard to see the problem when you look at the longest continuous longitudinal temperature record in the world (the Central England Mean Temperature) averages - https://www.metoffice.gov.uk/hadobs/hadcet/graphs/ts_meantem...
My house was built in the early 1980's, it's becoming less and less suited to our climate now and that'll get worse.
Long term the plan is to re-insulate the loft, insulate the walls, install shutters on the flat windows (and look at them for the bay windows, our windows are a pain as they aren't flat and they usually open outwards), heat pumps/AC and PV (complicated by roof been east/west but if you panel both you get not far off the same as the same area facing south and more nicely you get power in mornings/evenings which is when we use the most (for much of the year anyway)).
The house my boy inherits will be more suited for the climate he'll be living in when he inherits it (hopefully not for another 30-40 years but the universe may have other plans).
Still, where I live a problem is that most residential buildings are designed to be warm in the winter first and foremost, without concern for potential summer overheating. But the latter has now become a real problem, and there’s often not much to do about existing buildings without extensive renovations but to install per-unit AC. At least there’s the fact that it can often be done with a heat pump so it’s also useful in the winter.
Teleheating is very common around here, and cities have started building telecooling networks to complement heating, simply circulating cold water to be used as a heat sink. But building comprehensive pipe networks is of course slow and expensive.
I know this because I grew up in a house in Florida built in the 1950s, with no A/C. Southern vernacular architecture includes high ceilings (so the heat rises above the people), lots of windows (to let the air go through and heat escape), and with the house raised off the ground (so cooling air flows underneath). While my house didn't have it, another typical design element is a wraparound porch, to provide extra shade and let the windows stay open even when it rains.
If you build for A/C in the South then you want a building with good insulation and little airflow, to save on power. If the A/C doesn't run then these places get very warm, humid, and stuffy. Nearly every house is built this way.
Further, if you are used to the chill that A/C provides then your body doesn't adjust to the heat.
The US Southwest has its own vernacular architecture. The days are hot and the night cool, so use thick adobe walls which take 12 hours for the heat of day to seep through. Close the windows in the morning to keep the cool in, open them at night to cool off, while the heat from the walls keeps the inside more moderate.
One unique characteristic of the eastern US is that people here live in a climate with hot and humid summers but imported the clothing norms of a subcontinent (Europe) with warm and dry summers. If you look at traditional — pre-colonial — dress in Africa or India, you'll find it's much less warm. Even in China, which resembles the eastern US from a climate perspective, loose and lightweight clothing (silk!) was much more common prior to the global adoption of western norms.